Standard Bank has moved to take total control of insurance giant Liberty Holdings, of which it already has a more than 50% stake, offering to buy the remaining shares for around R12 billion in what it says is a natural move as it looks to grow its footprint in the financial services sector.
The lender, South Africa’s biggest in terms of assets at R2,5 trillion, says it wants to acquire the balance of 96 million shares in Liberty that it does not currently own, at R14,40 per ordinary share plus 0.5 of Standard Bank’s ordinary shares. Liberty will also pay its shareholders R11,10 per share through a “special distribution”. In all, that amounts to about R88 per share.
Liberty’s share price soared on news of the deal in early trading on Thursday, climbing by nearly 25% to R84.20 per share, its highest in a year and a half. The jump in Liberty’s share price, and its lower PE ratio compared to its competitors, may mean Standard Bank is getting the business on the cheap.
PE, or price-to-earnings, ratio, is the tool used by investors to determine whether a stock is overvalued or undervalued. A high PE ratio could mean that a company’s stock is overvalued, or else that investors are expecting high growth rates in the future. Liberty’s forward PE was at 8.6, against Santam and Momentum’s forward PE of 11.6.
Investment strategist at UnumCapital, Lester Davids, said Liberty had consistently traded at discount relative to its peers.
“This could be seen on a price-to-earnings, price-to-book and embedded value. At first glance, the transaction makes sense in terms of capital efficiency, as well as providing a holistic solution to clients across divisions of the two businesses,” said Davids.
Liberty’s chief executive David Munro told Business Maverick in an interview that the final offer was subject to a rigorous valuation and the fact that the independent board assigned to evaluate the offer had indicated its support of the deal to shareholders meant they viewed the price as fair.
“They indicated a firm intention that they will recommend this to shareholders, so you can glean from that they feel that the decision is a fair price,” Munro said. “For us, it’s a very difficult one because we made such a significant loss last year in the face of Covid, so it’s hard to look at the PE and imply a valuation from there.”
Standard Bank said the offer represented a premium of 32.6% on the closing price on Wednesday of Liberty’s listed shares on the JSE.
“The Boards of both SBG and Liberty believe that SBG’s acquisition of 100% of Liberty and integrating Liberty fully into the greater group will facilitate the creation of a united and formidable competitor in financial services in Africa with compelling scale,” Standard Bank said in a statement.
Standard Bank, which operates in 20 countries on the African continent, has held majority shares in Liberty since 1999. Liberty has around 3,2 million customers across Africa with more than R770-billion of assets under management. — Daily Maverick