Outrage over proposed mandatory HIV-testing

HUMAN rights activists and members of the public have expressed outrage at Sadc’s proposal to initiate a compulsory universal HIV- testing in all member states, as a means to reduce new infections.
REPORT BY PHYLLIS MBANJE

The idea was initiated by President Robert Mugabe during the Aids Watch Africa briefing at the just-ended Sadc summit in Malawi.

It received a lot of support from other leaders, who felt that drastic measures were now required to contain the scourge.

However, members of the public and human rights activists have received the news with varied responses, with many openly opposing the idea.

Mandatory HIV and Aids-testing has always been fraught with emotion, misunderstanding and lack of information.

Regionally and internationally, it has failed to be implemented due to its implications on human rights.

“No matter how grave the situation, HIV-testing should always be on voluntary basis if we want to see the required results,” said Tafadzwa Ruwende, a male student nurse.

“I do not understand why heads of state would even try to initiate a debate on that issue. It is unethical, just as it is in contravention of basic human rights. In a world where we champion the right to choose, mandatory testing is not an option,” he said.

A nurse counsellor with Population Services International (PSI) said it defied logic that the subject should be introduced at this point, when great strides had already been made using the voluntary testing method.

“As a counsellor, when a client comes for testing it is stressed that they are doing so voluntarily. If at any point during the session the client feels they no longer want to continue, we end it right there,” she said.

“The success of the counselling session and the measures that follow thereafter like treatment plans, are premised on how ready the client is to know their status. If one is forced, they may not be able to deal with their results should they turn out to be positive.”

Choga Mahoto from Waterfalls in Harare had no kind words for Malawian President, Joyce Banda for equating HIV and Aids to epidemics like polio, whereby everyone is forced to take vaccines against the disease.

“It is worrying when a head of state says HIV-testing should just be like taking a vaccine for polio. HIV and Aids have many issues like stigma, which makes it difficult to equate them with other diseases,” he said.

Banda came out strongly supporting Mugabe at the summit, saying there was no need to bring in the human rights aspect.

“When we were dealing with epidemics like polio, everybody was forced to take vaccines. Why is it that when it comes to HIV and Aids, rights come into the equation?” said Banda.

Also speaking on the issue, the chairperson for the Zimbabwe Association of Doctors for Human Rights (ZADHR), Rutendo Bonde said the move was a violation of basic human rights.

“Consent is the pivotal principle in any medical procedure. If you take that away, then we have big problems,” she said.

Another member of ZADHR, who declined to be named, said the organisation was mooting issuing out a statement on the issue of mandatory testing.

Bonde would neither confirm nor deny that ZADHR would issue a statement, saying she would only comment after having a board meeting, scheduled for yesterday.

However, besides the ethical and rights issues of mandatory HIV and Aids-testing, there are logistics and the costs to consider as well because those who would have tested positive would eventually be put on anti-retroviral therapy (ART).

The National Aids Council said about 1,2 million people were living with HIV in Zimbabwe and 600 000 of them were in need of anti-retroviral drugs.

3 Responses to Outrage over proposed mandatory HIV-testing

  1. chembere yekwachivi August 25, 2013 at 5:40 pm #

    That’s a noble idea. But you must not be forced to reveal your status to anyone unless you wish to do so. This is good for patients, they are treated early and life expectancy Will rise. The chances of spreading the virus are low when one is on treatment with an undectable viral load. There are more benefits. i think let’s debate about this

  2. Spencer August 25, 2013 at 6:54 pm #

    This is a clear cut violation of human rights. In that case let all diseases be made compulsory to be tested on everyone starting with Robert Mugabe

  3. Mandayebwe August 26, 2013 at 12:33 am #

    I think given where our nation is with a high HIV infection rate, the idea of increasing HIV testing is a good one provided that suitable counselling and ARV therapy is made available for those tested. I would not support mandatory testing but would support increasing the occasions for which HIV testing, notification to patients and ARV support is done. Right now I feel like ”tiri kudya uroyi nokunyarana” in the name of protecting human rights & patient’s privacy.

AMH logo

© 2014 The Zimind. All Rights reserved.

DMMA logo